On eBay
As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase
Searching eBay…
Series
Astonishing 7
Atlas Tales
Issue Information
- Cover Date
- December 1951
- Cover Titles
- Nightmare!
They Dwell in Darkness!
Out of My Mind!
Paid in Full - Cover Credits
-
Joe Maneely pencils signed
- Contributions
-
Tom Lammers: Cover Creator Credit
My ComicsChecking your account…
Current market pricing for Astonishing #7 shows a latest raw sale of VG sold for $110 on November 12th, 2021, a latest graded sale of CGC 6.0 sold for $266.99 on September 4th, 2023.
Raw price ranges include Very Good 3.0-4.0 $65-$204 (3 comps).
Graded price ranges include CGC 3.0 $64.01-$128 (2 comps); CGC 4.0 $284 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated October 18th, 2026.
Stories
Nightmare
Credits
Joe Maneely pencils signed
Backfire
Credits
Credits not yet documented
Paid in Full
Credits
Harry Lazarus pencils guess
Out Of My Mind
Credits
John Romita pencils signed
Out of the Darkness
Credits
Joe Maneely pencils signed
Market Pricing
Last Updated
2026-10-18 07:35:03
Last Raw Sale
VG sold for $110 on November 12th, 2021
Last Graded Sale
CGC 6.0 sold for $266.99 on September 4th, 2023
Sources Represented
eBay sold via PriceCharting
Raw Price Ranges
Very Good 3.0-4.0
$65-$204 (3 comps)
Graded Price Ranges
CGC 3.0
$64.01-$128 (2 comps)
CGC 4.0
$284 (1 comp)
CGC 5.0
$361.23 (1 comp)
CGC 5.5
$525 (1 comp)
CGC 6.0
$266.99-$800 (3 comps)
Featured eBay Matches
View Sold Comps (22)
Grade
Price
Date
Provenance
Record
6.0
$800
January 23rd, 2025
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) 1951 Atlas Comics Astonishing 7 CGC 6.0 CR-OW Joe Maneely Pre Code Horror 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
6.0
$266.99
September 4th, 2023
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 Pre-Code Horror Golden Age Vintage Atlas Comic 1951 CGC 6.0 1951
Original listing is no longer available
6.0
$266.99
September 4th, 2023
eBay sold via PriceCharting
Original listing is no longer available
5.5
$525
May 27th, 2023
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 CGC 5.5 1951 1621589011 1951
Original listing is no longer available
FINE- 5.5
$132.50
April 7th, 2023
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING #7-ATLAS-Joe Maneely-HORROR-PRE-CODE-1951-pch-great cover FINE- 5.5 1951
Original listing is no longer available
FINE- 5.5
$127.50
April 7th, 2023
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING #7-ATLAS-Joe Maneely-HORROR-PRE-CODE-1951-pch-great cover FINE- 5.5 1951
Original listing is no longer available
VG/FN 5.0
$275
June 12th, 2023
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 (1951) Atlas VG/FN (5.0) Horror! Joe Maneely cover! Golden Age!! 1951
Original listing is no longer available
5.0
$361.23
August 7th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING 7 CGC 5.0 LINGERIE GIRL BED COVER PRE CODE HORROR ATLAS COMICS 1951 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
VG+
$180
September 1st, 2025
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 Nice Pre-Code Horror Golden Age Marvel Atlas Comic 1951 VG+ 1951
Original listing is no longer available
Very Good+
$110.51
November 23rd, 2021
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 Atlas Pre-Code Horror 1951 - Very Good+
Original listing is no longer available
VG
$65
July 21st, 2024
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING 7 - 1951 -MANEELY COVER + 3 STORIES, ROMITA ATLAS PRE-CODE HORROR 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
4.0
$284
October 27th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing 7 | CGC 4.0 | Scarce! Maneely cover. Lazarus art | 1951 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
VG
$110
November 12th, 2021
eBay sold via PriceCharting
Original listing is no longer available
VG-
$204
April 25th, 2023
Heritage Auctions Astonishing #7 (Atlas, 1951) Condition: VG-....
Auction 121547, Lot 14319
3.0
$128
September 27th, 2021
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 CGC 3.0 (1951 Atlas Comics) Pre-Code Horror Joe Maneely Cover 1951
Original listing is no longer available
3.0
$64.01
September 27th, 2021
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing 51 * CGC 3.0 * RARE #7
Original listing is no longer available
GD 2.0
$94
October 22nd, 2024
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING #7 GD 2.0 ATLAS COMICS 1951 PRECODE HORROR! 1951
Original listing is no longer available
FR 1.0
$56.89
October 18th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing #7 FR 1.0, maybe FR/G complete 1951 Atlas horror 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
lower grade but complete
$70
October 19th, 2024
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING #7 Atlas 1951 Maneely Romita Art Lower Grade But Complete PCH 1951
Original listing is no longer available
-
$147.50
April 14th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING TALE OF SUPERNATURAL- 1951-DEC VOL1. NO.7 ISSUE- JOE MANEELY- 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
-
$120
April 8th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) ASTONISHING #7-ATLAS-HORROR-1951-pch-great GGA Cover 1951
Original listing is no longer available
-
$110
November 12th, 2021
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Astonishing stories of the supernatural, #7, 1951 1951 #7
Original listing is no longer available
Looking for the full run? Browse the Astonishing checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.
Issue Overview
Astonishing #7 was published in December 1951. It is part of the Astonishing series, which ran from April 1951 to August 1957.
Cover credits include Joe Maneely.
Atlas Tales indexes 5 stories for this issue, including "Nightmare." Indexed story credits include Joe Maneely and Harry Lazarus, among others.