On eBay

As an eBay Partner, I may be compensated if you make a purchase

Searching eBay…
Atlas Tales icon

Series

Mystic 5

Atlas Tales

PublishedMarch 1951 – August 1957
Issue Numbers1 – 61
Total Issues61
View Checklist
Issue Information
Cover Date
November 1951
Cover Notes
The story looks to be by Hartley and the art there is quite similar to that on the cover, so Hartley would be my guess here. - Ger Apeldoorn
Chris Rule pencils or inks? - Nick Caputo
Sighted Date Stamp
Aug ? 1951
Indicia Frequency
bi-monthly
Indicia Publisher
Classic Syndicate, Inc.
 
Cover Titles
Face?
It Creeps by Night!
The City That Vanished!
 
Cover Credits
Unknown pencils
 
Contributions
Doc V.: Cover Creator Credit
Nick Caputo: Cover Creator Credit
Ger Apeldoorn: Cover Creator Credit
My ComicsChecking your account…
View My Comics
My Comics

Add owned copy

My Wantlist

Add to wantlist

How much is Mystic #5 worth? View Full Market Prices

Current market pricing for Mystic #5 shows a latest raw sale of raw sold for $157.50 on June 30th, 2025.
Raw price ranges include Fair/Good $40 (1 comp); Very Good 3.0-4.0 $99.99 (1 comp).
Pricing data last updated October 28th, 2026.

Stories

Market Pricing

Last Updated 2026-10-28 07:35:03
Last Raw Sale raw sold for $157.50 on June 30th, 2025
Sources Represented PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation)

Raw Price Ranges

Fair/Good $40 (1 comp)
Very Good 3.0-4.0 $99.99 (1 comp)
View Sold Comps (4)
Grade
Price
Date
Provenance
Record
5.0
$157.50
June 30th, 2025
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Mystic #5 1951 Atlas Pre-Code Horror Vampire Text Story Jerry Robinson 1951
Original listing is no longer available
5.0
$171.50
November 21st, 2021
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Mystic, #5, 1951 1951 #5
Original listing is no longer available
3.0
$99.99
January 28th, 2025
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) Mystic #5 - 1951 Pre-Code Golden Age Horror 1951
Original listing is no longer available
1.5
$40
May 11th, 2022
PriceCharting (eBay sold aggregation) 1951 MYSTIC ISSUE #5 COMIC BOOK GOOD COMPLETE
Original listing is no longer available

Looking for the full run? Browse the Mystic checklist to see every indexed issue in one place.

Issue Overview

Mystic #5 was published by Classic Syndicate, Inc. in November 1951. It is part of the Mystic series, which ran from March 1951 to August 1957.

Atlas Tales indexes 5 stories for this issue, including "The City That Vanished." Indexed story credits include Jerry Robinson and Hy Rosen, among others.